Monday, September 14, 2015

Responsibilities of an academic researcher/writer - new piece at Asthma Allergies Children

New piece at Asthma Allergies Children

Myths abound when it comes to food allergies - no doubt about it. Even worse is when the popular media feeds the myth machine. Science journalism is tough because the work needs to be readable, factually accurate, and give non-scientist readers a sense of its significance and potential impact without over- or under-selling the complicated science itself. In other words, science writers translate what seems like a whole other language (academic journals) into something average human beings can understand and appreciate. When done well, science journalism/writing is a work of beauty. Some days, it feels about as rare as winning a Pulitzer Prize.

Most science writers are knowledgeable about science, but are not scientists themselves. Mistakes happen, and scientists endlessly gripe about how the media seem to get it wrong more than they get it right. Scientists who also happen to write for the popular media are a rare, but powerful voice. I love the branding of The Conversation - academic rigor, journalistic flair - because I want to believe it. Is this finally a media outlet that can marry those two worlds?

Academic rigor, journalistic flair?
By Greek , possibly Athenian (Princeton University Art Museum) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
I'm now skeptical after reading "The myth of flying peanuts: not so deadly after all." I expected so much more from author, Tim Spector, who has both serious science and writing credentials. You don't get to be a professor at a well-known institution by making unsupported claims in your peer-reviewed journal articles. Why should it be any different in the popular media? Those rare, mythical Centaurian-like creatures are in a powerful position to influence change for the better in the media. Unfortunately, they are also in a position to do incredible harm when they appeal to their baser media flair side. Scientists shouldn't get to take a vacation when they don't have the threat of peer-review. I wish we lived in a world where regardless of a person's credentials, their work could be judged by the merit of their arguments. We don't live in that world. Appeal to authority speaks loudly because people just don't have the time or energy to vet everything for themselves.

I've vetted "The myth of flying peanuts: not so deadly after all" for you at Asthma Allergies Children in the following piece - “Rigor” Mortis: Post Mortem on an Airborne Allergy Article.

A big thank you to editor, Henry Ehrlich.

17 comments:

  1. Strangely enough allergy to nuts is not rampant here in our country. I don't know a person who's allergic to peanuts really.

    Thanks for this insightful article though.

    ReplyDelete
  2. To support the thesis statement appropriately, professional writing services which offer professional academic writing services help students understand the value of using relevant, cited, and up-to-date facts and figures.Creating a College or University Essay

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jessica Martin you are absolutely right about academic researcher and writer. It is true that Science writer must have science knowledge. I want here to know about best personal statement editing services.

    ReplyDelete
  4. great blog having wonderful information about food allergy and science journalism, law personal statement law personal statement are useful to see how effectively they present theiir statments ,

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Glad to know this information.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Academic research paper is very important for PhD students bust sometimes they can't manage time to write . i hope your service will help them visit website and it'll help you to know more about the academic papers writing.

    ReplyDelete
  8. You write some unique point of views about Asthma Allergies Children , it will help many parent to protect their child. everyone should read pharmacist personal statement to know more about the problem and solutions

    ReplyDelete
  9. You have shared the info about the academic and researcher. It involves a precise set of books, a predetermined info and a close define of what's going to be educated once try this and the way to students within the course of the tutorial year.

    ReplyDelete
  10. There has some differences between these three words. In this article it has been said so well with an example that my confusion is gone totally. click here to see more about the quality writing services.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Great food science jobs article. Rose Fanta Search is a Food Science Recruiter for the food science jobs industry. We are a food science recruiting firm that recruits food manufacturing and food science applicants for food science jobs.

    ReplyDelete
  12. We live in a time where fresh graduates are struggling to find decent work, let alone deal with their mounting student loans. And if they do find a decent job, it does not necessarily involve the skills that they have acquired from courses that they have taken in college. Dissertation Writing Services

    ReplyDelete
  13. Why think about going to your state college and your state college framework rather than private colleges and colleges?
    AD List 24 Classifieds

    ReplyDelete
  14. Your way to enlighten everything on this blog is actually pleasant, everyone manage to efficiently be familiar with it, Thanks a great deal.
    nutrition facts banana

    ReplyDelete
  15. An auto-pilot equation that not other Children's Book Publishing aide can coordinate. No writer needs to filter through several pages of Children's Book Publishing procedures and thoughts. To be fruitful around here, you have to come to the heart of the matter, and get it going.children book and author

    ReplyDelete
  16. They have to devote time on both activities and both have an equal impact on their life. In this regard, the students also need to complete a lot of academic tasks as part of their education. writing service review

    ReplyDelete